Calling all nerds

Guard Dad

Administrator
Staff member
Odd question

In one of my computers, I have always used a 3rd hard drive inside as the backup drive. I use Memeo as the backup app.

Works fine, but it seems like the hard drives for the backup only last 2-3 years. Would a NAS drive last longer?
 
Depends....by NAS drive, do you mean replacing that single drive with a drive meant for installation in NAS devices or backing up to a NAS that contains multiple drives?

If the former, yeah, maybe, perhaps...probably a toss-up on if it'll last longer.

If the latter, assuming the NAS has multiple drives with some sort of RAID configuration that would use all the drives at the same time, they would all last longer.
 
Probably... as long as the communication software is still compatible with the latest release of Windows. Chrome doesn't have any problems with backups. Just sayin'. :whistle: :whistle: :whistle:
 
Depends....by NAS drive, do you mean replacing that single drive with a drive meant for installation in NAS devices or backing up to a NAS that contains multiple drives?

If the former, yeah, maybe, perhaps...probably a toss-up on if it'll last longer.

If the latter, assuming the NAS has multiple drives with some sort of RAID configuration that would use all the drives at the same time, they would all last longer.
Just replacing that drive with a NAS drive, or maybe a surveillance drive. I'm thinking maybe one that is more heavy duty.
 
Probably... as long as the communication software is still compatible with the latest release of Windows. Chrome doesn't have any problems with backups. Just sayin'. :whistle: :whistle: :whistle:
It's not the OS, it's a hardware problem. I'm assuming the drives just wear themselves out.

I might could set the backup app to back up less often instead of the incremental backup I'm now using.
 
I suppose the bearings could wear out, but the memory surface should last a good long time. Try going with a high quality heavy duty drive that is equivalent to the drive assigned to the operating system. That drive has been handling the VS for the whole system and has not worn out. The back up drive only has to handle the I/O involved with the copying of the other drives. Does your backup app initialize the disk before the backup and flag bad sectors or does it do a replace of the data? I could never get a backup to copy everything to another disk, which worked out well, because I couldn't find software that would restore individual items like we could on the Mainframe.
 
I suppose the bearings could wear out, but the memory surface should last a good long time. Try going with a high quality heavy duty drive that is equivalent to the drive assigned to the operating system. That drive has been handling the VS for the whole system and has not worn out. The back up drive only has to handle the I/O involved with the copying of the other drives. Does your backup app initialize the disk before the backup and flag bad sectors or does it do a replace of the data? I could never get a backup to copy everything to another disk, which worked out well, because I couldn't find software that would restore individual items like we could on the Mainframe.
I was assuming that the backup drive was spinning like crazy all the time, where the D drive (I use SSDs for C drive) was slowing down and even stopping when at idle. But I might be wrong. The other drives have been working just fine, and in the most recent case, I used the same type of drives for D and backup.

I am also assuming that NAS or Surveillance drives are meant for durability over read/write speed, and might run slower and last longer.
 
Just replacing that drive with a NAS drive, or maybe a surveillance drive. I'm thinking maybe one that is more heavy duty.

I'm not sure I trust the marketing info provided for those surveillance/NAS specific drives. Couldn't hurt to try one though. Even if they have the same mechanical parts as other drives, if reconfigured to run slower they should last longer....in theory.
 
I'm not sure I trust the marketing info provided for those surveillance/NAS specific drives. Couldn't hurt to try one though. Even if they have the same mechanical parts as other drives, if reconfigured to run slower they should last longer....in theory.
I did a lot of surveillance camera work for awhile. I NEVER had a hard drive fail, even after years of running. And they had to be running 24/7 due to the recording aspect.
 
Surveillance drive installed and backup is underway. We'll see if it lasts.

This was my office computer. I brought it home to clean it up and will use it somewhere. Still a very powerful machine.
 
This seems to be working well. I refurbed the computer; replaced some of the drives, a couple of noisy fans, reloaded windows and all the apps. it. It's about four years old, but still a very powerful machine. 8 cores running at about 4400 mhz, 32 gig RAM. Still a fast machine, even my today's standards.

My wife might be taking on a remote bookkeeping gig, and if so she'll need a more powerful machine that will run multiple monitors. This one will do it.
 
Back
Top